Skip to main content

Mark-to-Market Rule

THE mark-to-market accounting rules are being brought a little closer to economic reality — accompanied by misplaced howls of outrage. True, the ostensibly independent Financial Accounting Standards Board agreed to alter a portion of the rules only under extreme pressure. Still, the standards have forced many financial institutions to overstate losses on trillions of dollars worth of assets, intensifying the global financial crisis.


Defenders of the rules say they protect bank investors and changing them will allow institutions to hide future losses. To the contrary, they have helped drive down the value of bank stocks, made shorting the shares much easier and caused bank stockholders to lost hundreds of billions of dollars in such companies as Citigroup Inc. and Bank of America Corp. William M. Isaac, a former chairman of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., told a House Financial Services subcommittee “MTM accounting has destroyed well over $500 billion of capital in our financial system.”


Since capital can be leveraged about 10 times in making loans, the rules have destroyed over $5 trillion of lending capacity.


The problem with mark-to-market accounting is that it officially has presumed there’s a functioning market in whatever asset is being valued — and that means a deal between a willing buyer and seller that isn’t being forced to sell. Actually, no such market exists for many mortgage-backed securities.

DISTRESS SALE

Nevertheless, according to testimony, accountants have required many banks to calculate values based on distressed sale prices. That has meant large write downs even on mortgage-backed securities that the institutions intend to hold to maturity.


Take the case of the Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta. Following the mark-to-market rules, it wrote down the value of its portfolio of mortgage backed securities by $87.4 million in last year’s third quarter. Its actual projected loss on the securities: $44,000. For the fourth quarter the bank recorded a further $98.7 million loss on the securities.


That result makes no sense when the bank doesn’t trade such assets. However, if the current market value declines significantly and stays down for an extended period of time — a condition known as other-than-temporarily-impaired — mark-to- market has been required, a bank spokesman said.


A writedown might still be required under the changes FASB approved yesterday. Yet auditors can now use “significant professional judgment” when valuing illiquid securities. That’s what they should have been allowed to do all along.

CASH FLOW

The change will make it harder for accountants to continue to protect themselves from lawsuits by using some trade, no matter at what low price, to determine a security’s value. With the new leeway, the Atlanta bank should be able to value its mortgage-backed securities by calculating the expected cash flow — the monthly mortgage payments from homeowners — and applying an appropriate discount. That’s the approach the bank used to determine the $44,000 third-quarter loss.


The key points in this example are that almost all the mortgages involved are still performing and the bank plans to hold the securities to maturity — and yet large writedowns were required.
Think of it this way. There are millions of U.S. homeowners who are “underwater” with their mortgages. That is, they owe more than the value of the home in today’s depressed housing market.

PUTTING UP MONEY

That’s hardly good news, and it might make it impossible to refinance the mortgage because of the lack of equity. On the other hand, the house hasn’t changed. It’s still providing the same shelter and other amenities to the household, and if the family’s financial circumstances haven’t gone into a tailspin, the monthly mortgage payments can still be made.


The family doesn’t have to put up money to cover the difference between the mortgage and the lower market value. Nor should the Atlanta bank have to take a big hit on its reported income because some other mortgage-backed securities owner sold in a depressed market.


FASB wisely backed away from a tentative proposal to allow auditors to assume that limited trades in an inactive market were always distressed sales. That would have gone too far.


Now accountants are supposed to use their judgment in assessing the meaning of such trades. That’s a big improvement over just using the last transaction price, as many auditors have been doing.

RECOVERING WRITEDOWNS

Now FASB has to deal with how banks deal with recoveries of previous write downs due to other than-temporary-impairment losses when there’s evidence that loss is no longer there.


A March 27 letter sent jointly by the five federal regulators of financial institutions — the Comptroller of the Currency, the Federal Reserve Board, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., the National Credit Union Association and the Office of Thrift Supervision — urged FASB to add such a recovery to current earnings.


Since the losses were subtracted from earnings, that would be an equitable way for FASB to go — and soon.

Popular posts from this blog

Mutual Fund Review: Kotak Opportunities

    DESPITE a portfolio of around 57 stocks, a large-cap tilt and exposure to derivatives, debt and cash, it is not a fund for the cautious. True to its calling, it scouts for opportunities and doesn't hesitate in taking concentrated sector and stock bets. This leads to extreme returns. In the bull phase (June 15, 2006 to January 8, 2008), it delivered 91.26 per cent against the 81.29 per cent average of other opportunity funds. Unsurprisingly, it shed higher in the bear hug of 2008. While in the recent run up (March 9, 2009 to June 30, 2010) it delivered 85 per cent against its peers 87 per cent. Its charm lies in its capability to identify sector trends ahead of time. In 2005, it rode the FMCG wave and the move paid off. In the first quarter of 2006, it focused on metals. In 2007, its exposure to construction and metals that resulted in a superb performance. In 2008, it was overweight on the least-hit FMCG sector, which helped it get away with an average fall. More recently...

How to invest in the Stock Markets?

Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Buy Gold Mutual Funds Call 0 94 8300 8300 (India)   One of the trickiest things in life is making a decision when to enter and exit the stock market. Investing in the stock markets is all about timing. Yet the timing is never right .Stocks never seem to reach the optimum price one wants .When share prices are expected to fall down to abysmal levels they rise and are soon out of one’s price range. When share prices are at low levels one keeps waiting for them to hit rock bottom and when they rise one has missed the bus. Stock markets are all about keeping one’s emotions in check. One must stand the true test of time.   What are interest rate sensitive stocks? When interest rates rise consumers who purchase expensive items such as cars on credit might postpone them. Discretionary spending is cut .Customers might postpon...

ASBA Option for Initial Public Offer (IPO)

IPO (initial public offering) applicants, particularly the unsuccessful ones, often have to face a double whammy of sorts. On the one hand they fail to get allotment of shares and on the other, they lose out on the interest during the period their money is locked —that is, if they have opted for the traditional method of issuing cheques for depositing the application money. However, if they choose the ASBA (Application Supported by Blocked Amount) facility, they can circumvent this problem. But do note that you cannot decide to make two applications – one by way of cheque payment and the other through ASBA. If you do so, it could be rejected on the grounds that it constitutes multiple applications. Introduced by Securities and Exchange Board of India ( Sebi ) in 2008, using ASBA has become mandatory for all non-retail investors. Retail investors, though, continue to have the option of choosing between the old and new mechanisms. However, it is in your interest to opt for ASBA. He...

Tata Growth Renamed as Tata Mid Cap Growth

Tata Mutual Fund has announced a change in the name of Tata Growth to Tata Mid Cap Growth with effect from November 22, 2012.   As per the investment strategy, the scheme invests a minimum of 65% in equity and equity related securities of well researched companies of the midcap segment. Some of the best Tax Saving Mutual Funds available ( ELSS Mutual Funds ) ICICI Prudential Tax Plan Invest Online HDFC TaxSaver Invest Online DSP BlackRock Tax Saver Fund Invest Online Reliance Tax Saver (ELSS) Fund Invest Online Birla Sun Life Tax Relief '96 Invest Online IDFC Tax Advantage (ELSS) Fund Invest Online SBI Magnum Tax Gain Scheme 1993 Invest Online Sundaram Tax Saver Invest Online Edelweiss ELSS Invest Online ---------------------------------------- Happy Investing!! We can help. Call 0 94 8300 8300 (India) Leave your comment wit...

Important questions to ask your Life Insurance Agent

Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Buy Gold Mutual Funds Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300 Important questions to ask your Life Insurance Agent The problem with a surprising majority of life insurance buyers is their unwillingness to research the products that they are buying. Frequently enough, these buyers leave the purchase decision to their insurance agent; all that such buyers do is to write out the cheque. Even though most of us have been guilty of this behaviour at one point or another, we all recognize the necessity of engaging with the agent. Regardless of whether you are a first-time buyer of insurance or a veteran in this regard, one cannot underemphasize the importance of discussing with the agent the various aspects of policy purchase. While there is no end to the queries that you could put to your insurance agent, the following three questions are crucial. 1. What are my coverage r...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds Download Any Applications
Transact Mutual Funds Online Invest Online
Buy Gold Mutual Funds Invest Now