Skip to main content

Profits on sale of shares when taxable as capital gains & when as business income

 
Though the Income tax laws provides for taxation of profit on transfer of capital asset under the head capital gains, there are situations/cases when the activity of buying and selling of listed shares is treated as trading activity either by the tax payer or by the revenue authorities and any profit on it is taxed as business income.

In order to minimise such disputes and to guide the tax authorities and the tax payers,  the tax department has been issuing guidelines from time to time in this regards. In this article I will attempt to discuss the criteria, which play a determining role in deciding whether it becomes as capital gains or as business income.
Factors to be considered for deciding whether the income is business income or capital gains
 
The first instruction were issued vide Instruction No. 1827 dated 31.08.1989 on taxation of surplus arising on sale of shares guiding the tax authorities on various criteria to be applied for treating holding of shares as stock in trade or capital asset.One of the most important criteria to be applied under these instruction was to find out the intention of the tax payer. Where the purchase has been made with the sole intention of resale at a profit and the purchaser does not have any intention to hold the property for himself or otherwise for enjoying it, the presence of such an intention is a relevant factor and it would raise a strong presumption that the transaction is in the nature of trade and such securities shall be treated as stock in trade and thus profit liable to be treated as business income. However in case one invests in securities for the sole purpose of  earning dividends/interest over the years, the same can not be treated as stock in trade and any profit on sale of such asset will have to be treated as capital gains.

Likewise the nature of trade or business carried on by the tax payer shall also be relevant for this purpose. In case of stock brokers any purchase and sale of securities shall be treated as business income unless there are other circumstances to warrant other treatment like intention to hold it for generating regular income in future. Likewise the volume of transactions in securities will also point towards it being in the nature of trade. So in case the tax payer has indulged in such transaction of purchase or sale of securities sporadically, the presumption of it being capital asset is very high.

One of the other indicators is whether a particular assessee is buying or selling the securities or whether he has merely invested his money with a view to earning further income or is holding it for carrying on his other business. In former case the surplus shall be treated as business income and in later case the same shall be treated as capital gains.

In addition to the nature of business, volume of transactions and  intention,  the treatment of the securities in the books of accounts by the tax payer as investment is also a guiding factor for treating the surplus as capital gains. However such treatment in the books alone would not be conclusive evidence in case some other facts points to other direction. For example where the tax payer has been dealing in the securities on almost daily basis though showing all such securities as investment. In such circumstances the treatment of such securities as investment in the books of accounts  itself is wrong.

The central government has issued revised instruction in 2007 vide Circular No. 4/2007 dated 15.06.2007 providing further clarity on the criteria to be used for treatment of specific security as stock in trade or capital asset. It has provided that whether a particular holding of shares is by way of investment or forms part of stock-in-trade is a matter where the knowledge and conduct of the tax payer is important. So it is the responsibility of the tax payer to provide evidence in support of his contention. It has further provided that it is the substance of the nature of transactions which is important factor like how the books of accounts have been maintained,  or the magnitude of purchases and sales of such securities or the ratio between purchases and sales. All these factors evaluated together will help the tax payers as well as the revenue authorities to arrive at a valid and rational conclusion.

It is not that all the holdings of securities of a particular assessee can either be treated as stock in trade or capital asset. The assessee can treat some of the shares as capital assets and some as stock in trade. The tax payer can even treat some shares of a Company as stock in trade and other shares of the same company as capita assets. So it is possible for an assessee to have two portfolios, one as an investment portfolio comprising of securities which are treated as capital assets and the other one as a trading portfolio comprising of stock-in-trade which the tax payer treats as trading assets. Where an assessee has two portfolios clearly segregated, the tax payer can have income from both the sources.

Various Courts have also held that when the assessee has shown some securities as capital assets in previous years and the same has been accepted by the income tax officials then, the tax officer can not take a different stand later on unless there are strong evidence to warrant such a change of opinion.

The government has also advised the tax officers that while evaluating whether particular security is stock in trade or capital asset,  it is totality of facts and circumstances which are to be considered and no  single principle would be decisive and can be considered in isolation. So the overall effect of all the various guidelines and principles should be considered to determine whether, in a given case, the securities are held by the assessee as investment or stock-in-trade. So what is important is to consider the distinctive character of the transaction and the security. In each case, it is the total effect of all relevant factors and circumstances that determines the character of the transaction.
-----------------------------------------------
Invest Rs 1,50,000 and Save Tax under Section 80C. Get Great Returns by Investing in Best Performing ELSS Mutual Funds

Top 10 Tax Saver Mutual Funds to invest in India for 2016

Best 10 ELSS Mutual Funds in india for 2016

1. BNP Paribas Long Term Equity Fund

2. Axis Tax Saver Fund

3. Franklin India TaxShield

4. ICICI Prudential Long Term Equity Fund

5. IDFC Tax Advantage (ELSS) Fund

6. Birla Sun Life Tax Relief 96

7. DSP BlackRock Tax Saver Fund

8. Reliance Tax Saver (ELSS) Fund

9. Religare Tax Plan

10. Birla Sun Life Tax Plan

Invest in Best Performing 2016 Tax Saver Mutual Funds Online

Invest Online

Download Application Forms

For further information contact Prajna Capital on 94 8300 8300 by leaving a missed call

---------------------------------------------

Leave your comment with mail ID and we will answer them

OR

You can write to us at

PrajnaCapital [at] Gmail [dot] Com

OR

Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300

-----------------------------------------------

Popular posts from this blog

Section 80CCD

Top SIP Funds Online   Income tax deduction under section 80CCD Under Income Tax, TaxPayers have the benefit of claiming several deductions. Out of the deduction avenues, Section 80CCD provides t axpayer deductions against investments made in specific sector s. Under Section 80CCD, an assessee is eligible to claim deductions against the contributions made to the National Pension Scheme or Atal Pension Yojana. Contributions made by an employer to National Pension Scheme are also eligible for deductions under the provisions of Section 80 CCD. In this article, we will take a look at the primary features of this section, the terms and conditions for claiming deductions, the eligibility to claim such deductions, and some of the commonly asked questions in this regard. There are two parts of Section 80CCD. Subsection 1 of this section refers to tax deductions for all assesses who are central government or state government employees, or self-employed or employed by any other employers. In...

ULIP Review: ProGrowth Super II

  If you are interested in a death cover that's just big enough, HDFC SL ProGrowth Super II is something worth a try. The beauty is it has something for everybody — you name the risk profile, the category is right up there. But do a SWOT analysis of the basket, and the gloss fades     HDFC SL ProGrowth Super II is a type-II unit-linked insurance plan ( ULIP ). Launched in September 2010, this is a small ticket-size scheme with multiple rider options and adequate death cover. It offers five investment options (funds) — one in each category of large-cap equity, mid-cap equity, balanced, debt and money market fund. COST STRUCTURE: ProGrowth Super II is reasonably priced, with the premium allocation charge lower than most others in the category. However, the scheme's mortality charge is almost 60% that of LIC mortality table for those investing early in life. This charge reduces with age. BENEFITS: Investors can choose a sum assured between 10-40 times the annualised premium...

What is Electronic Clearing Service (ECS)?

  As the name suggests, it's an electronic process through which money can be transferred from one bank account to another. According to RBI, this mode is usually used for regular payments and receipts, like distribution of dividend, interest, salary, pension etc. This mode is also used for collection of bills for telephone, electricity, water, various types of taxes, payment of EMIs , investments in mutual funds , payment of insurance premium etc. There are two types of ECS , like most other banking transactions, ECS credit and ECS debit. An ECS credit is used by a bank account holder , usually a large company or an institution for services like payment of dividend, in terest, salary, pension etc. If your mutual fund pays you dividend to your bank account, of all probability it is being paid through ECS credit.ECS debit, on the other hand, is used when a company or an institution is getting money from a large number of people. For example if you are investing in a mutual fund sc...

Bharat Bond ETF

Top SIP Funds Online   The government of India has paved the way for the launch of India's first corporate bond ETF called as Bharat Bond ETF. Edelweiss Mutual Fund will be managing it. The fund is mandated to invest in AAA-rated bonds of select public sector companies (see the table 'List of constituents and their proportions in the portfolio'). The government has a threefold objective behind launching this product. One, to deepen the liquidity of the Indian debt markets and provide a gateway for easy retail participation. Two, to solve investors' dilemma of picking premium bonds. Lastly, to help the underlying government-owned companies raise funding for their operations. But does it make sense for you, the investor, to invest in it? Lets find out. What is the product? As the name suggests, it is an exchange-traded fund which will be listed on a stock exchange from where its units can be bought and sold post launch. It will have two variants - one maturing in 3 ye...

How to Pick Top Performing Mutual Fund Schemes

Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Buy Gold Mutual Funds Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300   How to Pick Performing Schemes  Funds that continue to stay in the top grade of performance over longer periods are the ones to bet on, advise investment experts   The mutual fund performance charts of the past few months make for an impressive reading. Funds across all categories boast of stellar returns. Sample this: The mid and small cap category has averaged 77 percent return over the past 12 months, with the best fund delivering a staggering 120 percent. The tax-saving funds also average an impressive 51 percent, including a fund which has soared 92 percent. Many of the table-toppers are funds of proven quality and track record. However, there are also schemes that are not that well-known. Some of these have rarely made it to the performance charts in the past, yet, of late, they bo...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds Download Any Applications
Transact Mutual Funds Online Invest Online
Buy Gold Mutual Funds Invest Now