Skip to main content

Return from stocks capital gains or business income?

Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online

Call 0 94 8300 8300 (India)

 


It depends on the assessing officer's interpretation. To be on the safe side, have a separate trading account

You have just filed your income tax returns. You have ensured all the profits you have made from your equity investments have been accounted for and paid the 15 per cent short- term capital gains tax for all investments held for less than one year. Still, how come the income tax department has sent a notice asking you to pay tax on your "business income".

You have no other income other than your salary, but the tax assessing officer has decided to charge your income from stock market transactions as business and tax you accordingly.

This issue is subjective and, therefore, sees maximum litigation,.  The income from stock market transactions has to be seen by the number of cumulative trades conducted and the intention – whether the objective is to do business or not. This cannot be known by reading the investor's mind. But it can be seen from or is reflected in the way trades are transacted." For instance, an investor might buy shares worth ₹ 1 lakh and sell it in, say, eight months if he has made 25 per cent returns, though the intention was investment. Does this become business income? According to Praveen Nigam, managing director of Amplus Consulting, investors could buy stocks with the intention of either trading or investment. But even if the stocks are held as investments, since stock markets are risky, if the investor sees an opportunity, he will sell the share irrespective of the period of holding. It is a very thin line and each case is different.

The intention in either of the cases is to get good returns and not necessarily to earn dividends.

In the case of listed equities, there is no long- term capital gains tax if held for more than 12 months. Only securities transaction tax is deducted. If it is sold before 12 months, the investor has to pay short- term capital gains tax, which is 15 per cent. Technically, if there is a long- term capital gain in listed equities, there is no debate.

However, in the case of shortterm capital gains, that is if the listed stocks are sold in less than 12 months, the issue becomes more contentious. Then, the basic question is whether the profits made are short- term capital gains or income from business and profession.

If it is classified as business gains, then the investor has to pay tax at 33 per cent tax. But investors can claim all exemption on expenditure incurred on conducting the business, such as salary, office administration expenses, conveyance, etc.

Ideally, investors should take acall on trading based on the opportunity, rather than with an aim to avoid tax.

Since each case is treated differently, in case you get a notice from the I- T department, you must argue your case in totality and represent all aspects. Consider the volume of transaction, frequency of trades, number of shares in each transaction, and so on.

One way of proving the intention is to show there is a cautious, deliberate attempt to earn dividend from holding the stock for the long term. However, some companies are known to offer high dividend. There are investors who buy such stocks just before companies announce a dividend. Will this, then, be considered abusiness income? One stray transaction of buying and taking dividend and selling may not have much of an impact. But buying huge amounts can be seen as intention of earning of profit. Nigam cites the case of a salaried person who sold some portion of his equity portfolio within two months of buying and some within six months, while a major portion of the shares he held for longer than one year. The assessing officer was ready to accept that the portion was held for more than one year was long- term capital gains but insisted the shares held for a shorter term should be deemed as business income.

However, the tribunal held that just because the shares were held as investments or just because it was sold in less than a year, it could not be treated as business income. Finally, it was allowed as capital gains.

Nigam says the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) has a broad directive on classification. CBDT says if you hold shares, you must bifurcate your portfolio into stock in trade and ' investment'. The shares in the ' stock in trade' portfolio are meant for trading and the shares in the ' investment' portfolio are meant for investment. So, you will be liable to pay business income if you sell shares in the 'stock in trade' portfolio, Nigam explains.

Classification of shares in the book of accounts is not conclusive evidence and is not decisive. In every case, the court may have a different opinion because the conduct of business is personal.

Happy Investing!!

We can help. Call 0 94 8300 8300 (India)

Leave your comment with mail ID and we will answer them

OR

You can write back to us at PrajnaCapital [at] Gmail [dot] Com

---------------------------------------------

Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds ( ELSS Mutual Funds ) to upto Rs 1 lakh and Save tax under Section 80C.

Invest Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online

Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online

These links can be used to Purchase Mutual Funds Online that are regular also (Investment, non-tax saving)

Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms from all AMCs

Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Applications

These Application Forms can be used for buying regular mutual funds also

Some of the best Tax Saving Mutual Funds available ( ELSS Mutual Funds )

  1. ICICI Prudential Tax Plan Invest Online
  2. HDFC TaxSaver Invest Online
  3. DSP BlackRock Tax Saver Fund Invest Online
  4. Reliance Tax Saver (ELSS) Fund Invest Online
  5. Birla Sun Life Tax Relief '96 Invest Online
  6. IDFC Tax Advantage (ELSS) Fund Invest Online
  7. SBI Magnum Tax Gain Scheme 1993 Invest Online
  8. Sundaram Tax Saver Invest Online
  9. Edelweiss ELSS Invest Online

------------------

Best Performing Mutual Funds

    1. Largecap Funds Invest Online
      1. DSP BlackRock Top 100 Fund
      2. ICICI Prudential Focused Blue Chip Fund
      3. Birla Sun Life Front Line Equity Fund
    2. Large and Midcap Funds Invest Online
      1. ICICI Prudential Dynamic Plan
      2. HDFC Top 200 Fund
      3. UTI Dividend Yield Fund
    1. Mid and SmallCap Funds Invest Online
      1. Reliance Equity Opportunities Fund
      2. DSP BlackRock Small & Midcap Fund
      3. Sundaram Select Midcap
      4. IDFC Premier Equity Fund
    1. Small and MicroCap Funds Invest Online
      1. DSP BlackRock MicroCap Fund
    1. Sector Funds Invest Online
      1. Reliance Banking Fund
      2. Reliance Banking Fund
    1. Tax Saver MutualFunds Invest Online
      1. ICICI Prudential Tax Plan
      2. HDFC Taxsaver
      3. DSP BlackRock Tax Saver Fund
      4. Reliance Tax Saver (ELSS) Fund
    2. Gold Mutual Funds Invest Online
      1. Relaince Gold Savings Fund
      2. ICICI Prudential Regular Gold Savings Fund
      3. HDFC Gold Fund

Popular posts from this blog

Understanding Your Cibil Credit Information Report

   WE ARE all familiar with the anxiety and uncertainty that we feel when applying for a loan. After all, it's the lender who decides whether we can own our dream home, our first car, or whether our children can pursue higher education. In a nutshell, a better life depends on the lender's decisions.    While other factors do play a part in the lender's decision, the Cibil Credit Information Report ( CIR ) plays a crucial role in a lender's decision to approve a loan application.    Previously, lenders would treat all loan seekers equally. Each applicant, if approved by the lender's internal credit policy, would be charged at the same interest rate for a particular loan size and purpose. The lenders would charge a higher interest rate to all the borrowers, in order to compensate for the possible default of a small portion of the loan disbursed. In other words, it's like a professor (the lender) punishing an entire class (borrowers) for the mischief played b...
Read more

How much to invest in gold ?

Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Buy Gold Mutual Funds Call 0 94 8300 8300 (India) Let your motivation dictate the share of the yellow metal in your portfolio Enough has been said and written about gold as an investment option. The latest argument is that the craze for gold among Indian households is endangering our country's balance of payments. The policymakers are busy trying to find ways of discouraging investment in gold, but if households keep the common good in mind, they would be paying the market price for gas cylinders as they do for, say, their mobile phone bills. After all, private decisions are driven by private motives. So, how should a household look at gold from its own perspective? Gold is primarily acquired for its merit as a store of value. Even if the worst crisis hits a family, the gold that it holds could be put to use anywhere in th...
Read more

Time-tested methods to pick a good mutual fund

Proper understanding of a fund is important as it enables investors to keep a tab on its actual performance THERE are various types of mutual funds and one way of segregating them is on the basis of active or passive management. Th is makes the understanding of the nature of the fund easy for a lot of investors, as it shows the basis on which investment decisions will be made. Some funds also have a mixture of both active and passive management. Su ch funds need to be considered carefully if they are to be selected as an investment avenue. Here is a look at the manner in which such funds operate and its impact on decision-making. Mixture : The selection of the portfolio of an equity oriented mutual fund can be done in an active manner. The fund manager can take the decision about which stocks should be bought and sold by the fund. On the other hand, there can be a passive fund where the decision making is not in the hands of the fund manager as a specific index is followed for...
Read more

Save Tax With Mutual Funds

Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Buy Gold Mutual Funds Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300       Mutual funds are ideal as long term investment avenues for retail investors. To encourage investments in this avenue, the Government of India offers investors a spate of tax benefits thus ensuring maximum benefit from mutual funds held beyond a year. Sample some of the key benefits and refer to the table for a detailed list of tax rates for different types of schemes ·        Avail deductions under Sec 80C of the Income Tax Act by investing up to a maximum of Rs. 1 lakh in designated Equity Linked Savings Schemes (ELSS). Such investments have a compulsory lock in period of 3 years. ·        First time retail investors in equity with a gross total income of up to Rs. 12 lakh can invest up to Rs. 50,000 in specific MF schemes un...
Read more

Diversification is key to gain more

Even those who prefer debt for its safety are looking at more options    It is not often that you find more than a couple of asset classes producing good returns at the same time. Invariably, assets such as gold and equity don't perform in tandem, and hence it was easier to allocate to them in line with the risk profile of the investors. In the last couple of quarters, however, more than one asset has turned attractive - gold, debt and equity. In line with the trend, you even have monthly income plans with a combination of more than two assets.    In the past, those who stuck to debt were a different class of investors who didn't wish to take risk with their money. The changing lifecycles and the growing integration of investment markets across the globe have pushed even individual investors to embrace the concept of asset allocation. Hence, you have individuals who were using debt to park profits being prepared to take advantage of other assets.    For instance, when the...
Read more
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds Download Any Applications
Transact Mutual Funds Online Invest Online
Buy Gold Mutual Funds Invest Now