Skip to main content

Mutual Funds vs ULIPs

 

What's on the table?

IRDA has proposed the following charge structure to be implemented by October 1, 2009.

 

Overall ULIP charge structure:

1. For policies with tenure less than or equal to 10 years: Overall charges are capped at 3 per cent of gross yield; fund management charges (FMC) have been restricted at 1.5 per cent

2. For policies with tenure over 10 years: IRDA has capped total charges at 2.25 per cent of which the FMC will not exceed 1.25 per cent

 

Other charge structures:

- The above cap will exclude mortality and morbidity charges

- No surrender charges are applicable post 5 years of policy

- From October onwards, insurers will also have to give on maturity a certificate to policy holders showing year-wise premiums paid, charges deducted, fund values, partial withdrawals (if any) and the final payment made

 

All existing products that do not meet the requirements of this circular should be withdrawn or modified by December 31, 2009.

 

Your benefits

The regulation will be good for investors:

1. It will increase returns

As per the new ruling, a fund earning a gross yield (returns generated without inclusion of charges) of 12 per cent has to give a net yield (returns generated post inclusion of charges) of 9.75 per cent back to investors.

 

For example: If you take a policy with premium of Rs 100,000 per annum for a term of 10 years, given the cap on overall expenses (year-on-year) at 3 per cent; the fund value at the end of the term would be Rs 14.78 lakh.

Currently, the overall expense (YoY) stands at around 3.75 to 4 per cent; in that case the maturity value stands at around Rs 13.97 lakh. That is, you'd get Rs 81,000 at maturity.

 

2. The mandated disclosures will enable you to make an informed decision

 

Level playing field, yet? Stand point on ULIPs and MFs: They are different investment avenues meant for different types of investing.

 

Mutual funds work better when your objective is short term in nature and you can afford a risk profile ranging between 'Moderate-High'. On the contrary, ULIPs should be considered only when you have a medium or long term objective. Also, it falls under the 'Moderate' risk category, essentially when you are planning retirement; children education, etc.

 

ULIPs or Mutual Funds - How to choose?

 

Consider these factors while comparing the two avenues.

1. Most MF distributors are now charging a fee – typically on AUM (assets), this is as good as increasing the Fund management charges. This could, in some cases, turn out to be a higher percentage than the entry load that was being paid on the invested amount!

 

For example: If you are making regular investment of Rs 50,000 per annum each in an MF and in a ULIP, over a 10 year and 15 year period, the corpus that would be generated in both cases would be:

 

 

Avenues  10 years   15 years 

ULIP        739,180    1,434,668 

MF           732,935    1,327,109

 

Assumptions:

Expense ratio for ULIPs: 2.25 per cent (10-year term); 3 per cent (15-year term)

Expense ratio for mutual funds currently ranges between 1.84 per cent to 2.5 per cent; we are assuming an expense ratio of 2.15 per cent - percentage charged on AUM is assumed at 1 per cent (thereby the total of charges being 3.15 per cent)

Growth in both cases is assumed at 10 per cent

 

In the above case, ULIPs would work better, however, for a retailer who does the mutual fund investment directly without going through a distributor / financial advisor, the AUM charges would not be applicable and that would increase the corpus derived from mutual funds.

 

2. If one were to bring both mutual funds and ULIPs on the same platform, then the element of insurance needs to be added, which would further increase the cost on mutual funds (in case of ULIP the mortality cost is charged till the fund value does not exceed the sum assured, post which it becomes nil, a term cover would charge a flat premium throughout the term).

 

3. The proposed EET (Exempt-Exempt-Taxable) regime could be a dampner, especially in case of mutual funds. The ULIP policies availed prior to the implication of the EET regime would still enjoy tax-free returns. While, in the case of mutual funds, the sale date will be considered and irrespective of when the investment was made, if the sale happens post EET regime then the returns would be taxable.

 

Conclusion:

It is becoming obvious that MFs and ULIPs are moving towards immense rationalisation; with the focus from now on being on the quality of investment advice.

 

The IRDA focusing on reduction of long term costs is a step in the right direction keeping in mind that the ULIP should be considered mainly for the long term.

 

This is just the beginning of a new era of transparency in investment solutions which will enable investors reap better value on their investments.

 

Popular posts from this blog

ASBA Option for Initial Public Offer (IPO)

IPO (initial public offering) applicants, particularly the unsuccessful ones, often have to face a double whammy of sorts. On the one hand they fail to get allotment of shares and on the other, they lose out on the interest during the period their money is locked —that is, if they have opted for the traditional method of issuing cheques for depositing the application money. However, if they choose the ASBA (Application Supported by Blocked Amount) facility, they can circumvent this problem. But do note that you cannot decide to make two applications – one by way of cheque payment and the other through ASBA. If you do so, it could be rejected on the grounds that it constitutes multiple applications. Introduced by Securities and Exchange Board of India ( Sebi ) in 2008, using ASBA has become mandatory for all non-retail investors. Retail investors, though, continue to have the option of choosing between the old and new mechanisms. However, it is in your interest to opt for ASBA. He...

How to choose between different tax-saving options

With many types of tax-saving instruments available for individuals, but the amount of investment allowed to avail exemption limited, one needs to plan well. Apart from non-tax factors — return on investment, flexibility to exit, recurring nature of investment, etc — the main tax considerations include tax impact not only at the time of investment, but also on future income and exit from the tax-saving scheme (commonly known as exempt at the time of contribution, exempt at the time of accumulation and exempt at the time of withdrawal).   One must look at the lock-in period for investment/exit and the quantum of general or specific limit for investment for tax savings. In the general category, where tax savings are available under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, following instruments take a front seat as they are EEE schemes with relatively lower lock-in periods:   Equity Linked Savings Scheme is operated by various fund managers where the proceeds are inves...

Birla SunLife FTP Series Dividend

Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Buy Gold Mutual Funds Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300   Birla SunLife Mutual Fund Dividend   Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund has announced dividend under the dividend option of Birla SL FTP Series GY Reg-D , Birla SL FTP Series GY Reg-DQ , Birla SL FTP Series GY Direct-D and Birla SL FTP Series DA-D .   The quantum of dividend will be the entire distributable surplus as on the record date. The record date has been fixed as May 08, 2014. For further information contact Prajna Capital on 94 8300 8300 by leaving a missed call Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300 Leave your comment with mail ID and we will answer them OR You can write back to us at PrajnaCapital [at] Gmail [dot] Com ---------------...

SBI Emerging Businesses

Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Buy Gold Mutual Funds Call 0 94 8300 8300 (India)   We like this scheme for the assumed risks it takes by investing in emerging business themes based on exports and outsourcing for which it has been handsomely rewarded.   Strategy Although the fund watches out for the opportunities in sectors based on general economic patterns, its concentrated exposure to certain sectors makes it similar to sector funds. According to the fund manager, there is no restriction on buying stocks as long as the valuation comfort exists. Since 2009, this fund has also increased its exposure to small-cap allocation that went up from an average 24.8 per cent in 2008 to an average of about 45 per cent as of now. The average market capitalisation of this fund is Rs 7,361 crore, which is on the lower band in the category. This fund restricts investm...

Mutual Fund Review: Kotak Opportunities

    DESPITE a portfolio of around 57 stocks, a large-cap tilt and exposure to derivatives, debt and cash, it is not a fund for the cautious. True to its calling, it scouts for opportunities and doesn't hesitate in taking concentrated sector and stock bets. This leads to extreme returns. In the bull phase (June 15, 2006 to January 8, 2008), it delivered 91.26 per cent against the 81.29 per cent average of other opportunity funds. Unsurprisingly, it shed higher in the bear hug of 2008. While in the recent run up (March 9, 2009 to June 30, 2010) it delivered 85 per cent against its peers 87 per cent. Its charm lies in its capability to identify sector trends ahead of time. In 2005, it rode the FMCG wave and the move paid off. In the first quarter of 2006, it focused on metals. In 2007, its exposure to construction and metals that resulted in a superb performance. In 2008, it was overweight on the least-hit FMCG sector, which helped it get away with an average fall. More recently...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds Download Any Applications
Transact Mutual Funds Online Invest Online
Buy Gold Mutual Funds Invest Now