Skip to main content

Motor insurance

TRANSFER formalities at the regional transport office on purchase/sale of vehicles can take time. While the process is pending, the insurance policy continues in the name of the seller. What happens if the vehicle meets with an accident or is stolen during this period? If the buyer lodges a claim, the insurer refuses to indemnify him as the policy is not in his name. If the seller lodges the claim on behalf of the buyer, the insurer contends once the vehicle is sold, he ceases to have an insurable interest, and, hence, is not entitled to lodge aclaim. Thus, though the premium has been collected, the claim is paid neither to the seller nor the buyer. Is this permissible? Narayan Singh purchased asecond-hand Maruti van, insured for `1,40,000 by the original owner. Within five days, it met with an accident while Singh and his family were travelling from Varanasi to Muzaffarpur. The vehicle was totally damaged. As the claim was not settled, Singh filed a complaint before the Muzaffarpur District Forum, which ruled in his favour and directed the company to reimburse 1,40,000 with an eight-per cent interest per annum, plus `5,000 as compensation and cost.

The insurer appealed to the Bihar State Commission, which set aside the forum's order and dismissed the complaint, stating the Muzaffarpur District Forum did not have the territorial jurisdiction and, also, because the policy had not been transferred in Singh's favour.

Singh then approached the National Commission. With regard to policy transfer, the commission said the view taken by the State Commission was erroneous and could not be justified in view of Section 157 of the Motor Vehicles Act, which provides that an application for transfer has to be made within 14 days of the vehicle's purchase. In this case, the accident had occurred within five days, much before the expiry of this period. Also, India Motor Tariff Regulations say that upon a vehicle's transfer, the benefits under the policy would automatically accrue to the new owner. So, the rejection was unjustified.

Regarding the objection to the territorial jurisdiction of the Muzaffarpur District Forum, the commission observed that Singh resided at Muzaffarpur and was using the vehicle there. Even as the accident took place in Patna district, the insurance company had a branch at Muzaffarpur. Hence, the commission ruled the Muzaffarpur District Forum could entertain the dispute.

Accordingly, it set aside the State Commission's order and upheld the decision given by the District Forum in Singh's favour. It also increased the rate of interest from 8 to 12 per cent a year.

The commission came down heavily on the insurance company for adopting an unjustified stand and suppressing the relevant India Motor Tariff Regulation in several cases. As a deterrent and penal measure, it levied a punitive cost of `1lakh on the insurer, payable to the Consumer Legal Aid Account. The commission warned insurers to be careful about not taking a stand contrary to the regulations framed by the India Motor Tariff and the Insurance Regulatory Development Authority. The order copy was also sent to the latter's chairman . [Shri Narayan Singh v/s New India Assurance – IV (2007) CPJ 289 (NC)].

Some companies continue rejecting similar claims. Recently, a consumer complaint was filed against Bajaj Allianz General Insurance for ignoring such a claim, despite the judgement having been brought to its notice
 

Popular posts from this blog

Group Health Insurance

Buy Group Health Insurance Online   For Human Resources, the biggest challenge today is to decide whether medical benefits should be offered to employees or not, what type of plans should be offered, what will be the cost and how will the cost be split between employees and employer. Well, most of these are subjective and would depend on a lot of factors including company size, average employee salary, etc. However, this article will give you a fair idea on how you should go about deciding these factors: 1. Why offer group health insurance benefit to employees : Studies have proved that retention rates among employers offering GHI are much higher than the ones who are not offering. Moreover, the cost of providing this benefit as a percentage of salary is very low as compared to the perceived value. As an example, say if average salary of an employee in your organization is 4 LPA. If you decide to offer a health insurance benefit to him for a Sum insured of ...
Read more

ICICI Prudential Dynamic Plan Invest Online

Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Buy Gold Mutual Funds Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300   ICICI Prudential Dynamic Plan             Invest Online This fund does remarkably well during falling markets, but fails to show the same prowess during a rising market. The fund sticks to its mandate to adapt to the dynamic nature of the market by shuttling between debt and equity. It takes aggressive asset calls in equity when the market surges by investing in quality mid-cap stocks. At the same time, it adopts a defensive strategy by investing in debt and cash when markets get overvalued, making it a good long-term choice.     For further information contact Prajna Capital on 94 8300 8300 by leaving a missed call     Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300   Leave your comment with mail ID and we will ...
Read more

Why credit history is critical?

Will you need a loan to buy a car or a house? Do you know why some people get their loans sanctioned quickly without any hassle, whereas others find that their approval is delayed or their application is rejected? If you want a loan, you will need to work to build a solid credit history because this can have a bearing on the ease with which you get loans. Read on to learn more about what is a credit history and how to build a good credit score. What is a credit history? Your credit history is a way of tracking your credit behaviour and habits — basically it shows how disciplined and regular you are when it comes to repaying your dues on loans that you have taken. It will show a complete record of your past borrowing and repayment record including details about any late payments or if you have defaulted on a loan. This track record is readily accessible to lenders and is used by them to when reviewing your loan application. Borrowers who have historically had a bad record of managing...
Read more

Birla Sun Life MIP II Savings 5

  Birla Sun Life MIP II Savings 5 - Invest Online   Have you traditionally been a debt investor but now wish to test waters in equities? Then, debt-oriented funds such as Birla Sun Life MIP II Savings 5 (Birla Savings 5), which have limited exposure to equities, may fit your requirement. With a five year return of 10.5 per cent compounded annually, the fund managed a good 3-3.5 percentage points more than its benchmark Crisil MIP Blended Index, as well as its category average. The fund appears well poised to capitalise on a falling interest rate scenario and has increased the average portfolio duration of its debt instruments in recent times. Suitability Birla Savings 5 is suitable only for conservative investors. If you want to make a beginning in equities and cannot take any short-term declines in your stride, then this fund will suit you. If you are already an equity investor and want to use a debt-oriented fund merely as a diversifier, then you may prefer peers from the HDFC and Re...
Read more

Stock Market Concepts: Derivatives and taxation

DERIVATIVES refer to an instrument, which derives its value from the value of something else — that is, an underlying asset. In India, the derivatives space has traditionally been the playground for large institutional investors who use it for hedging or for speculative activities. However, with time, we have seen a steep augmentation in the per capita income of an average Indian. Consequently, the appetite for investment in alternative instruments has transcended into the need to explore untested territories, and one of the most lucrative of all the available options, is the derivatives. Taxation Of Derivatives: Let's have a sharp overview of how taxability impacts the dealings in futures and options: Futures: Since, there is no transfer or delivery of the underlying asset in case of futures, the income or loss from it cannot be taxed under the head "capital gains". Therefore, depending upon the fact whether the assessee is a trader or an investor, the head of income...
Read more
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds Download Any Applications
Transact Mutual Funds Online Invest Online
Buy Gold Mutual Funds Invest Now