Skip to main content

Motor insurance

TRANSFER formalities at the regional transport office on purchase/sale of vehicles can take time. While the process is pending, the insurance policy continues in the name of the seller. What happens if the vehicle meets with an accident or is stolen during this period? If the buyer lodges a claim, the insurer refuses to indemnify him as the policy is not in his name. If the seller lodges the claim on behalf of the buyer, the insurer contends once the vehicle is sold, he ceases to have an insurable interest, and, hence, is not entitled to lodge aclaim. Thus, though the premium has been collected, the claim is paid neither to the seller nor the buyer. Is this permissible? Narayan Singh purchased asecond-hand Maruti van, insured for `1,40,000 by the original owner. Within five days, it met with an accident while Singh and his family were travelling from Varanasi to Muzaffarpur. The vehicle was totally damaged. As the claim was not settled, Singh filed a complaint before the Muzaffarpur District Forum, which ruled in his favour and directed the company to reimburse 1,40,000 with an eight-per cent interest per annum, plus `5,000 as compensation and cost.

The insurer appealed to the Bihar State Commission, which set aside the forum's order and dismissed the complaint, stating the Muzaffarpur District Forum did not have the territorial jurisdiction and, also, because the policy had not been transferred in Singh's favour.

Singh then approached the National Commission. With regard to policy transfer, the commission said the view taken by the State Commission was erroneous and could not be justified in view of Section 157 of the Motor Vehicles Act, which provides that an application for transfer has to be made within 14 days of the vehicle's purchase. In this case, the accident had occurred within five days, much before the expiry of this period. Also, India Motor Tariff Regulations say that upon a vehicle's transfer, the benefits under the policy would automatically accrue to the new owner. So, the rejection was unjustified.

Regarding the objection to the territorial jurisdiction of the Muzaffarpur District Forum, the commission observed that Singh resided at Muzaffarpur and was using the vehicle there. Even as the accident took place in Patna district, the insurance company had a branch at Muzaffarpur. Hence, the commission ruled the Muzaffarpur District Forum could entertain the dispute.

Accordingly, it set aside the State Commission's order and upheld the decision given by the District Forum in Singh's favour. It also increased the rate of interest from 8 to 12 per cent a year.

The commission came down heavily on the insurance company for adopting an unjustified stand and suppressing the relevant India Motor Tariff Regulation in several cases. As a deterrent and penal measure, it levied a punitive cost of `1lakh on the insurer, payable to the Consumer Legal Aid Account. The commission warned insurers to be careful about not taking a stand contrary to the regulations framed by the India Motor Tariff and the Insurance Regulatory Development Authority. The order copy was also sent to the latter's chairman . [Shri Narayan Singh v/s New India Assurance – IV (2007) CPJ 289 (NC)].

Some companies continue rejecting similar claims. Recently, a consumer complaint was filed against Bajaj Allianz General Insurance for ignoring such a claim, despite the judgement having been brought to its notice
 

Popular posts from this blog

Mutual Fund Review: Religare Tax Plan

Tax Plan is one of the better performing schemes from Religare Asset Management. Existing investors can redeem their investment after three years. But given the scheme's performance, they can continue to stay invested   Given the mandated lock-in period of three years, tax saving schemes give the fund manager the leeway to invest in ideas that may take time to nurture. Religare Tax Plan's investment ideas revolve around 'High Growth', which the fund manager has aimed to achieve by digging out promising stories/businesses in the mid-cap segment. Within the space, consumer staples has been the centre of attention for the last couple of years and can be seen as one of the key reasons for the scheme's outperformance as compared to the broader market. It has, however, tweaked its focus and reduced exposure in midcaps as they were commanding a high premium. The strategy seems to have worked as it returned a 22% gain last year. Religare Tax Plan has outperformed BSE 100...
Read more

Mutual Funds: Past Performance is not just everything

Many a times your agent / distributor / relationship manager tries to push you some mutual fund schemes by enticing you with a typical sales pitch…"Sir, this scheme has generated 20% returns in the past one year." And this sales pitch often gets louder when the market conditions have been favourable. Some of the agents / distributors / relationship managers have another unique way of luring you. They say, "Sir / madam this scheme has been awarded the best scheme award in the past by a leading business channel"... And hearing all these sales talks you investors very often get attracted and sign a cheque in favour of the respective scheme.   But please ask yourself do you hear these sales talks when the capital markets turn turbulent? Why is it so that your agent / distributor / relationship manager avoids talking to you during turbulent times of the capital markets and doesn't boast about returns generated by the respective funds or awards being conferred on t...
Read more

What are Tax savings Bank Fixed Deposits?

Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Buy Gold Mutual Funds Call 0 94 8300 8300 (India)   These are a special type of bank fixed deposits, of five-year tenure, which allow you to have tax benefits for investments of up to Rs 1 lakh per person per financial year. Investments in these FDs give tax benefits under 80C of the Income Tax act. These are not very liquid investments because the money is locked-in for five years. One also has the option to continue the FD for another five years after the lock-in ends. Happy Investing!! We can help. Call 0 94 8300 8300 (India) Leave your comment with mail ID and we will answer them OR You can write back to us at PrajnaCapital [at] Gmail [dot] Com --------------------------------------------- Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds ( ELSS Mutual Funds ) to upto Rs 1 lakh and Save tax ...
Read more

Good time to invest in Infrastructure Funds

Download Tax Saving Mutual Fund Application Forms Invest In Tax Saving Mutual Funds Online Buy Gold Mutual Funds Leave a missed Call on 94 8300 8300   Good time to invest in infrastructure The Sensex has gained almost 10 per cent from May 15 till date, while the CNX Infrastructure Index has gained almost 17 per cent in the period. The price to earnings ( P/ E) ratio of the BSE Sensex is 18.96; for the CNX Infrastructure Index, it is 24.57. The estimated P/ E for next year is 14.04 for the Sensex. Of the 24 companies that make up the CNX Infrastructure Index, six have a P/ E higher than 20. Does this mean infrastructure is fairly valued? Or, has it run up quite a bit? According to experts, barring stray companies, the infra sector is fairly valued and it is a good time to invest. Even if some companies are facing debt restructuring problems, once interest rates come down and regulatory norms become flexible, they will start giving good re...
Read more

Dynamic Bond Funds

Invest Mutual Funds Online Download Mutual Fund Application Forms Apart from liquidity and returns, tax efficiency is another factor which should be taken into account for such investments. Today, while you're getting decent, predictable returns from bank fixed deposits, they, along with FMPs, can be ruled out as options because of the lack of interim liquidity. Hence, the only other option that you have is a dynamic bond fund. While investments in dynamic bond funds can be a compromise in terms of returns, they are extremely liquid and more tax efficient.   Some of the dynamic bond funds that you can invest in are: UTI Bond Fund, Birla Sun Life Dynamic Bond Fund Templeton India Income Fund ------------------------------------- Invest Mutual Funds Online Transact Mutual Fund Online   Download Mutual Fund Application Forms from all AMCs Download Mutual Fund Application Forms   Best Performing Mutual ...
Read more
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds Download Any Applications
Transact Mutual Funds Online Invest Online
Buy Gold Mutual Funds Invest Now