Skip to main content

How to decide when to exit a Mutual Fund?



Investors are often more worried about exiting an equity mutual fund than they are about investing in it. This kind of anxiety is natural.


Most of us are oriented towards action. Once we have invested, the next action is to figure out the right time to redeem our investment. However, the answer to this question is actually very simple. It's the exact opposite of what you did while deciding when to invest and chose a fund to invest in. I'm not being facetious. Let's first look at the 'when' question. When did you invest? Obviously, when you had the money to spare. I mean, that's the first condition for being able to invest, right? The opposite of having money to spare is to need money. That's the right answer, then. You should redeem your investment when you need the money.

The real idea behind the above rule is that you should not try and time the market. If you are an equity fund investor, you should be in it for the long-term and you should be investing steadily. Most of all, you should not be watching the market like a hawk, ready to pounce on the first opportunity to 'book a profit', or some such idea. So the answer to the 'when' is entirely internal to your needs, rather than anything external.


The second part of the exit problem is figuring out if and when a particular fund has gone from being investment worthy to something that should be exited (and the money redeployed in another, presumably better, fund). Again, the answer is the exact opposite to how you chose the fund. When you invested, the first stage was to choose a fund that was of the right type. If you needed a very conservative option, you may have chosen an MIP, or an equity-oriented hybrid fund for a little higher returns or an aggressive multi-cap fund for the highest possible returns regardless of risk, and so on.


The first thing to do is to see if the category of fund still makes sense. Are the reasons why you chose to be aggressive or conservative still valid? If they aren't, then that's again one reason to redeem your investment and shift to a different fund. Again, the reason could be opposite to the one that made you choose the investment you initially made. Further, the reason is internal to your needs, rather than something that's based on what's happening in the markets.


Last, we come to the actual fund. Finally, we have a reason that's external. Over a period of time, a fund that you had chosen carefully may just have degraded enough to warrant getting out of. Here, too, the rule of the opposite holds. You may have, in all probability, chosen a fund after looking at its relative risk-adjusted performance, such as expressed in the Value Research star rating or some such system. A fund should have been better than its peers as well as its benchmark on a sustained basis for you to have chosen it to begin with. Therefore, you should get out and switch to another fund if it no longer qualifies on these counts. Of course, if you've realised that the choice was a poor one, then you should in any case switch right away.


Interestingly, it's implicit in this way of thinking that there's no such thing as 'hold'. Investment analysts often rate things in three levels — buy, sell and hold. At least in funds (and maybe in stocks, too), if something is worth keeping, then it's worth buying. It can't be that an asset is not good enough for fresh investment but is somehow good enough to hold if you already have it. It doesn't seem to make sense.
 

Popular posts from this blog

NPS Investment Choice for Safe Investors

Invest NPS Online       Whether they invested through SIPs or put in a lump sum amount, risk-averse individ uals have earned the highest returns. These are investors who stayed away from stocks and divided their NPS corpus between G class gilt funds and C class corporate debt funds. On average, gilt funds have given 9.75% annualised returns while corporate debt funds have churned out more than 11% in the past five years. As a result, the average return for ultra-safe investors in the past five years is in double digits. Even in the short term, ultrasafe investors have been the biggest gainers among NPS investors. Will the good times continue? The gilt funds of NPS are holding long-term bonds with an average maturity of over 19 years and a modified duration of about 9 years.These funds have done well because interest rate cuts have pushed down bond yields. But experts say this trend will not stay forever. NPS is a long-term investment and the bonds are predominantly held to matu...

Buy Health Insurance Plan even if you are covered with my Employer

Buy Health Insurance Plan Online Yes, getting a private insurance cover now, which extends beyond your retirement age, is recommended There are a few reasons why buying a health insurance plan may make sense even though you get medical insurance from your employer. Here are the points you need to think about. Firstly, your employer's insurance coverage will only protect you as long as you are employed with the company. The policy will terminate when you quit the job or when you retire. Post retirement is perhaps the phase when one needs it the most but you won't have it then. Moreover, buying a new insurance policy after the age of 50 means that there will be no coverage for pre-existing diseases.   Lastly, health insurance policy you get from your employer may or may not cover your dependants. ------------------------------ ----------------- Invest Rs 1,50,000 and Save Tax under Section 80C. Get Great Returns by Investing in Best Performing ELSS Mutual Funds Top 10 Tax Saver M...

Surrender ULPPs

  ICICI Pru LifeTime and ICICI Pru Lifestage are Unit Linked Pension Plans. Such insurance linked retirement plans are neither good investments nor do they offer sufficient insurance cover. As you can see, these have turned out to be bad deals. In the Lifetime plan, the fund value is not even equal to the total premiums that you have paid and in the Lifestage plan your return is just about 6% which is quite low. The mortality charges are as per your age which is why they have increased. Moreover, once these plans matures, you will have to compulsorily opt for annuity (regular income) and the annuity rates are generally modest. Assuming these plans mature in the next one year, it will be wise to surrender the plan now and curb your future commitments.   Before you choose to buy a term plan, you have to consider a few points. You need to insure yourself, only during the time you are working and your family is financially dependent on you. At the age of 59, not all insurance companies w...

Mutual Fund Review: Taurus Tax Shield

    Taurus Tax Shield has seen a turnaround in performance since 2007, but still remains a volatile offering… The fund has seen a turnaround in its performance since 2007 and has delivered impressively during market rallies since then. The portfolio is also more diversified. It contained its downfall to an average level in 2008 but is still one of the most volatile offerings in this category. Bold investors can look at this fund.   Strategy The fund manager invests across the market capitalisation and sectors. The selection of stocks is made on the basis of long-term business prospects and value creation. Fund Insight Launched in March 1996, the fund was a laggard with just two annual outperformances. Concentrated stock bets and high exposure to mid and small caps led to it being hit harder during market downturns. The number of stocks in the portfolio never exceeded 20 and it was not rare to see the top 5 holdings account for around 60 per cent of the portfolio. After b...

AXIS Long Term Equity Fund - The Best Tax Saver Fund for 2016

  AXIS Long Term Equity Fund - Invest Online   History:   The open ended mutual fund was launched on December 21 in the year 2009. It is benchmarked against BSE 200 and managed by the fund manager JINESH GOPANI. Initially the scheme was called as Axis tax saver fund but later it was renamed as Axis long term equity fund with effect from September 2, 2011. Nature of investment: As far as asset allocation is concerned, 97.52% of the stocks are equity and 0.02% is debt based. The primary focus of the fund is to invest in diversified equity stocks that have higher growth potential. Total asset size of the fund is in the tune of 4,996 CRORE as of June 30, 2015. Performance: The performance of the fund for one year, 3 years and 5 years are 23.6%, 29.9% and 19.1 respectively which are far greater than 6.4%, 14% and 5.6% benchmark figures. It has also preformed fairly well against SBI magnum Tax Gain (G) and HDFC tax saver (G). The growth comparison is enumerated below;                        ...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds Download Any Applications
Transact Mutual Funds Online Invest Online
Buy Gold Mutual Funds Invest Now