Skip to main content

Direct Taxes Code (DTC) and its effect on Fixed Maturity Plans (FMPs)

As the Income Tax Act makes way with effect from April 1, 2012, for the Direct Taxes Code, investors should be careful of overlapping investments. Meaning, investments where the IT Act is applicable while making it, whereas it is the DTC that will apply at the time of maturity.

For example, take the currently popular Fixed Maturity Plans (FMPs) of mutual funds. The attraction of these schemes is the tax efficiency they offer over bank fixed deposits. Both bank FDs and FMPs offer a similar rate of return. While the interest on bank deposits is taxed at the normal rate, in the case of FMPs (over a year), the 10 per cent (20 per cent with indexation) capital gains tax rate applies. Consequently, on a post-tax basis, an FMP is much more advantageous.

However, there is a significant issue. If you were to invest in, say, any one year FMP available currently, the IT Act applies at the time of making the investment. However, at maturity (2012-13), the DTC would apply. And, under the DTC, the tax advantage an FMP has may not be available. Let's understand how and why.

Basically, long-term capital gains from equity shares and equity-oriented mutual funds continue to be tax-free under the DTC. However, the current system of long-term capital gain taxation of non-equity MFs (10 per cent without indexation or 20 per cent with indexation) has been discontinued under the DTC. Though indexation will apply, the resultant capital gain would be added to the other income of the taxpayer and be brought to tax at the slab rates applicable. (Note here that it is not indexation per se but only the special rate of 20 per cent after indexation that is discontinued – indexation itself continues to apply).

Also, under the DTC, there is a significant departure from the ITA with respect to the method of determining whether a non-equity asset is long-term or not. For instance, under the ITA, a financial asset has to be held for over a year to qualify as long-term. Such a holding period is calculated from the date of purchase to the date of sale. For example, if you invest in an FMP in, say, August 2011, it would qualify as a long-term asset with effect from August 2012. However, under the DTC, the asset has to be held for over one year from the end of the financial year in which it was acquired. So, taking the same example, the FMP will qualify as long-term under the DTC only if held for over one year. From March 31, 2012, it will be considered a long-term asset only if sold anytime from April 2013 onwards.

So, let's see what these provisions mean for a typical 370-day FMP on offer currently (say in August). First, since the maturity of this FMP will be in August 2012, it is the DTC provisions that would apply, not those of the IT Act. That being said, since an FMP is a nonequity asset, the current system of 10 per cent (20 per cent with indexation) will not apply and, instead, the income will be subjected to the marginal rate of tax. Even this one could have lived with, since at least the net income subjected to tax would be lower due to applicability of indexation. However, in the above example, for the FMP to qualify as a longterm asset (and, hence, be eligible for indexation), it needs to be held for over one year from the end of the financial year in which it is purchased. That is, it needs to be held till April 2013. However, the maturity of the FMP will be in August 2012 and, hence, indexation will also not be applicable. Consequently, the income from such an FMP will be taxable just like interest from a bank deposit is – to be added to your other income and taxed at slab rates. The net effect would be that, given a similar rate of interest, there would be no difference whatsoever in the posttax return from a bank deposit and an FMP!

SUMMARY

The DTC is just round the corner. It is time various stakeholders take cognizance of this and tweak their offers in a way that would be optimal for the consumer. For example, the FMP tenure could have been so adjusted that every investor would end up qualifying for indexation benefits. Many may have already invested, not knowing (and not being warned) that at the time of maturity, the tax efficiency one has been used to all these years will not be available.

Investors, on their part, would do well to appreciate that this dual law applicability at the time of entry and exit is there for not only mutual fund schemes but also a host of other investments such as insurance plans, bonds and even to payments that earn tax deductions such as home loan instalments and tuition fees. Therefore, before committing funds for the long term, take care that the investments are tax-efficient and in conformity with the provisions of the DTC, rather than the current IT Act.
 

Popular posts from this blog

Birla SunLife Manufacturing Equity Fund

The Make in India program was launched by Prime Minister Naredra Modi in September 2014 as part of a wider set of nation-building initiatives. It was devised to transform India into a global design and manufacturing hub. The primary motive of the campaign is to encourage multinational as well domestic companies to manufacture their products in India. This would create more job opportunities, bring high-quality standards and attract capital along with technological investment to bring more foreign direct investment (FDI) in the country.   Why India as the next manufacturing destination?   The rising demand in India along with the multinational's desire to diversify their production to include low-cost plants in countries other than China, can help India's manufacturing sector to grow and create millions of jobs. In the words of our Honourable Prime Minister- Mr. Narendra Modi, India offers the 3 'Ds' for business to thrive— democracy,...
Read more

Total Returns Index brings out real Equity Funds Performers

From February, equity mutual funds have to change their benchmarks to account for dividend payments. Until now, funds used price-based benchmarks alone. TRI or total return indices assume that dividend payouts are reinvested back into the index. What this does is lift the overall index returns, because dividends get compounded. For example, the Sensex TRI index will consider dividend payouts of its constituent companies while the Nifty50 TRI index will consider dividends of its constituents. Using TRI indices as benchmarks comes on the argument that an equity funds earn dividends on the stocks in its portfolio, which they use to buy more stocks. Therefore, using an index that also considers dividend reinvestment would be a more appropriate benchmark. Shrinking outperformance With a stiffer benchmark, it is obvious that the margin by which an equity fund outperforms the benchmark would shrink. Rolling one-year returns from 2013 onwards, the average margin by which largecap funds out...
Read more

Stock Review: Havells

HAVELLS India's stock performance has been muted in the past three months, in line with the weak broader market. But, given the turnaround in its overseas subsidiary and the launch of new products in its consumer durable business, the company's stock may undergo a re-rating.    Havells is India's leading consumer electrical goods company, with consolidated sales of . 5,527 crore in the past four quarters. Its wholly-owned subsidiary Sylvania, which makes lighting and fixtures, has established brands in European, Latin American and Asian markets. Sylvania repre sented nearly half of the company's consolidated revenues in the first half of FY11.    Sylvania's poor financials hit Havells' consolidated performance in FY10. But, this has changed in the cur rent fiscal. Havells has reduced fixed costs of Sylvania by exiting from unprofitable businesses and outsourcing manufacturing to low-cost locations such as India and China. In the September 2010 quarter, Sylv...
Read more

Kisan Vikas Patra - KVP

  Kisan Vikas Patra (KVP) First launched in 1988, the Kisan Vikas Patra (KVP) is one of the premier and popular saving scheme offering from the Indian Postal Department. This product has had a very chequered history- initially successful, deemed a product that could be misused and thus terminated in 2011, followed by a triumphant return to prominence and popular consumption in 2014. The salient features of KVP are as follows- The grand USP- Money invested by the applicant doubles in 100 months (8 years, 4 months). KVPs are available in the following denominations- Rs.1000, Rs.5000, Rs.10,000 and Rs.50,000. The minimum purchase value for the KVP is Rs.1000. There is no maximum limit. KVPs are available at all departmental post offices across India. These certificates can be prematurely encashed after 2 ½ years from the point of issue. KVPs can be transferred from one individual to another and from one post office to another. ----------------------------------------------------- Inve...
Read more

Mutual Fund Review: Reliance Regular Savings Equity

    Despite high churn, Reliance Regular Savings Equity has managed to fetch good returns   In its short history, this one has made its mark. Though its annual and trailing returns are amazing, the fund started off on a lousy note (last two quarters of 2005). It managed to impress in 2006 and was turning out to be pretty average in 2007, till Omprakash Kuckian took over in November 2007 and wasted no time in changing the complexion of the portfolio. Exposure to Construction shot up to 28 per cent with almost 21 per cent cornered by Pratibha Industries and Madhucon Projects . Exposure to Engineering was yanked up (18.50%) while Financial Services lost its prime slot (dropped to 6.69%) and Auto was dumped. That quarter (December 2007), he delivered 54.66 per cent (category average: 25.70%).   When the market collapsed in 2008, thankfully the fund did not plummet abysmally. But even its high cash allocations could not cushion the fall which hovered around the category average. ...
Read more
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Invest in Tax Saving Mutual Funds Download Any Applications
Transact Mutual Funds Online Invest Online
Buy Gold Mutual Funds Invest Now